I belong to 28 Facebook groups — and I don’t actively participate in any of them.
Here are the two main reasons why:
And I’m not just throwing stones from a glass house here. I acknowledge that I haven’t done much to keep my own Facebook group — the New Comm Road Travelers — active and thriving.
But you tell me: Is my experience with Facebook much different from yours? Is there a magical component I’m somehow overlooking? If I put a little more effort into my Facebook group, would the collective membership suddenly be moved to do more than make a sporadic posting?
I’m hoping you’ll share a success story or two to erase my doubts. I want to hear about a Facebook group you lead, participate in, or know about that is working well.
Either drop a note in the comments section below, or shoot me an e-mail to bperson - AT - gmail - COT com.
[Facebook groups]
11 Responses
Kevin Dugan
11|Oct|2007 1Well Target won a Groundswell award for this one:
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=2345768493
And, with the kind of insight that gets you hired by Forrester, Jeremiah did
an analysis of Target and Wal-Mart’s Facebook marketing efforts.
http://www.web-strategist.com/blog/2007/09/10/facebook-sponsored-group-analysis-target-vs-wal-mart/
These are the only ones I know of that come close.
Michael Allison
11|Oct|2007 2I have the same experience.
I have a crisis communicators group on Facebook as well as one set up for my MA cohort for our on-campus residency. Neither have any significant involvement.
Eden Spodek
11|Oct|2007 3I share your frustration. I belong to 103 groups. Some start with greater momentum than others but the lack of RSS or another means of notifying members when there are any updates (not just to the profile or related news), detracts from the success and potential of Facebook groups.
I have a Facebook group and use Twitter as an extension of my blog. I’m disappointed I can’t integrate Twitter with my group. Likewise, I’m disappointed I can’t integrate the groups I administer with my personal profile. Both these features plus RSS would help make Facebook groups more viable and provide easier access to a wealth of valuable discussions and other content.
FYI, one of my favourite groups is run by HarperCollins Canada (http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=2345834133). I’m sure part of their success is because they give away at least 75 free books every month!
Joe Cascio
12|Oct|2007 4Same here, Bryan. I’ve pretty much stopped responding to Facebook group requests altogether. None have really appealed to me that much, but even if they did, I’d find Facebook’s UI to be a real problem. I don’t know why, but I find it almost impossible to figure out. It’s just this mad jumble of stuff all thrown in the same bucket. Facebook needs to figure out what it wants to be, and “everything to everybody” isn’t the right answer.
Bryan
12|Oct|2007 5@Eden: You addressed another frustration I have with groups that I might have included in the original past: the lack of integration between groups and personal profiles. Also, most (all?) Facebook applications can’t be used in groups. Why not?
Connie Bensen
12|Oct|2007 6Hi Bryan,
In August Facebook really opened up my networking beyond just commenting on blogs. My overview of that is here.
http://conniebensen.com/blog/2007/09/12/microsoft-becomes-human-thru-facebook/
I’ve also created an ACDSee group & there are 85 members. I’m Community Manager with ACDSee now, but the group is more informational rather than heavy marketing. Is it successful? I think so, because I notify people of chats & news from there & it’s growing.
And I have a series on Facebook including groups that outlines the way our community is using them for marketing their websites. They are having fun & really enjoying it! How successful they are with the marketing aspect hasn’t been assessed yet.
http://digiscrapinfo.com/wordpress/2007/08/18/facebook-is-in/
I am speaking on utilizing Facebook groups at a conference (widget on my blog) in Dec & will be sharing more information on how they can be used with just the investment of time.
Really it’s about being involved in a group (more than just joining it). If you have questions or want to talk about it - let me know. To date Facebook has been my primary place for networking & it started with the Web Strategy group there.
Nathan Ketsdever
01|Nov|2007 7I know that event promotions folks have used them rather successfully.
I tend to think that groups that have met in “real life” have a better chance of success (ie Podcamps) although there is the addition of being in social media that helps.
I know Mitch Joel had a group which seemed to get some chatter going (something like 15 video posts–although I imagine mostly by him), also Jeremiah’s web strategist group is reasonable. A facebook friend is running a group called Church 2.0 that he’s asked questions in and gotten some good response. Certainly, Connie Bensen’s experience above is worth noting.
» Facebook Advertising Connie Bensen: My Conversations
07|Nov|2007 8[…] There has been a discussion about groups & how people just join & don’t participate. Bryan Person had commentary on that on his blog. There are a number of Groups that provide me with value. The […]
Ravi G.
17|Nov|2007 9I totally agree that Facebook groups and causes are impossible to keep up with, and sifting through even the existing feeds is frustrating.
I’m really waiting for facebook to open up and adopt some best practices of blogging, rss feeds, etc.
Perhaps an amateur question: but do organizations have better chances creating a profile rather than a group. This way all the group’s friends get facebook feed updates when items are posted and updated? Solves the shortcomings of groups.
Emma
19|Dec|2007 10Yes I would also like to know if anyone has used a profile for their organisation successfully too, and how they went about it?
Howie
13|Mar|2008 11I created THIS Facebook group….
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=21237201144&ref=mf
The Facebook Group Platform is really quite limited, at least from personal experience, but the theme makes all the difference in the world. It certainly needs to be a lasting concept that will garner incredible, continual interest. The Colbert group managed to do this, with over a million members gained in less than a week (i believe that was it….)……but, like many facebook groups, it has been loosing members frequently now now that the ‘interest’ has died down……it was fun while it began for the first few weeks….it even gained some national media exposure, on the daily show, etc…..but, then, like many groups it just faced a decling…..
Ours has had slow, and steady growth…..it’s a rather lofty goal….and, some say it’s unreasonable….but, for the most part, i think alot of facebook members like to JOIN and invite their friends to groups that have monumental goals….
I created the logo….it’s simple, but intriguing, and gets frequent posts daily on the board…..
Here’s our growth statistics:
1,000 Members at 10:57 PM (EST) 11/06/2007
2,000 Members at 5:24 AM (EST) 11/08/2007
3,000 Members at 7:37 PM (EST) 11/08/2007
4,000 Members at 9:36 AM (EST) 11/09/2007
5,000 Members at 5:28 PM (EST) 11/09/2007
6,000 Members at 11:43 AM (EST) 11/10/2007
7,000 Members at 7:37 AM (EST) 11/11/2007
8,000 Members at 6:39 PM (EST) 11/11/2007
10,000 Members at 1:53 PM (EST) 11/12/2007
11,000 Members at 6:30 PM (EST) 11/12/2007
12,000 Members at 11:00 PM (EST) 11/12/2007
13,000 Members at 11:00 AM (EST) 11/13/2007
19,000 Members at 11:00 PM (EST) 11/13/2007
20,000 Members at 9:30 AM (EST) 11/14/2007
28,000 Members at 11:15 PM (EST) 11/16/2007
40,000 Members at 11:00 PM (EST) 11/19/2007
50,000 Members at 11:00 PM (EST) 11/21/2007
80,000 Members at 9:30 PM (EST) 11/29/2007
90,000 Members at 6:00 PM (EST) 12/2/2007
101,000 Members at 7:00 PM (EST) 12/5/2007
117,000 Members at 6:00 PM (EST) 12/10/2007
120,000 Members at 8:00 PM (EST) 12/11/2007
134,000 Members at 10:00 PM (EST) 12/25/2007
149,151 Members at 4:16 PM (EST) 02/23/2008
151,176 members at 9:26 PM (EST) 03/04/2008
151,240 members at 10:08 AM (EST) 03/05/2008
151,394 members at 7:45 AM (EST) 03/06/2008
151,648 members at 12:22 PM (EST) 03/07/2008
151,915 members at 11:38 AM (EST) 03/09/2008
152,066 members at 9:42 AM (EST) 03/11/2008
152,117 members at 10:23 AM (EST) 03/12/2008
Leave a reply
Search
Finding me elsewhere
Bryan Person's profile
Subscribe by e-mail
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
Archives
Categories
Creative Commons license
This work by Bryan Person is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 License.
A design creation of Design Disease
Copyright © 2007 - The Bryper Blog - is proudly powered by WordPress
InSense 1.0 Theme by Design Disease brought to you by HostGator Web Hosting.
FIORCET
CODEINE
VARDENAFIL
CELEBREX
ZOLOFT
PROZAC
SOMA
BONTRIL
LORAZEPAM
ZITHROMAX
ACOMPLIA
IONAMIN
RENOVA
SILDENAFIL
VALIUM
ULTRAM
XANAX
ATENOLOL
HOODIA
ULTRACET
AMBIEN
VICODIN
TRAMADOL
ALPRAZOLAM
OXYCONTIN
DIAZEPAM
KLONOPIN
ZYBAN
OXYCODONE
PROPECIA
ZOLPIDEM
CIALIS
KAMAGRA
ZYRTEC
VALTREX
TENUATE
ALLEGRA
WELLBUTRIN
LEXAPRO
TADALAFIL
TYLENOL
ADIPEX
CARISOPRODOL
MERIDIA
LEVITRA
ADDERALL
VIAGRA
METFORMIN
ATIVAN
PHENTERMINE
PAXIL
CELEXA
CIPRO
FLOMAX
XENICAL
TESTOSTERONE
LORTAB
CLARITIN
RIMONABANT
HYDROCODONE
FIORCET
SOMA
DETOX
TRAMADOL
PROPECIA
ZYRTEC
ZOLPIDEM
ALLEGRA
OXYCONTIN
DIAZEPAM
TYLENOL
CIALIS
XANAX
AMBIEN
VALIUM
ZYBAN
ALPRAZOLAM
VICODIN
OXYCODONE
HOODIA
RENOVA
TESTOSTERONE
XENICAL
ZITHROMAX
FLOMAX
PAXIL
LEVITRA
BONTRIL
CELEBREX
LORAZEPAM
ZOLOFT
WELLBUTRIN
RIMONABANT
IONAMIN
PROZAC
SILDENAFIL
ADDERALL
ADIPEX
CELEXA
KAMAGRA
CODEINE
TADALAFIL
ACOMPLIA
HYDROCODONE
PHENTERMINE
TENUATE
CARISOPRODOL
ULTRACET
VIAGRA
METFORMIN
ATIVAN
ULTRAM
LORTAB
KLONOPIN
CIPRO
VALTREX
LEXAPRO
VARDENAFIL
CLARITIN
ATENOLOL
MERIDIA
ZYRTEC
CLARITIN
TESTOSTERONE
ULTRAM
RENOVA
CARISOPRODOL
VALTREX
VALIUM
VIAGRA
LEXAPRO
CELEXA
ADDERALL
KAMAGRA
LORTAB
XENICAL
ADIPEX
PHENTERMINE
ZOLPIDEM
FLOMAX
ACOMPLIA
CIPRO
ULTRACET
BONTRIL
CELEBREX
TRAMADOL
CIALIS
TADALAFIL
WELLBUTRIN
METFORMIN
IONAMIN
OXYCONTIN
VARDENAFIL
SILDENAFIL
ZOLOFT
ALPRAZOLAM
DIAZEPAM
LEVITRA
HYDROCODONE
PROPECIA
LORAZEPAM
VICODIN
HOODIA
PAXIL
XANAX
PROZAC
ZYBAN
ALLEGRA
SOMA
ZITHROMAX
DETOX
OXYCODONE
CODEINE
TYLENOL
RIMONABANT
ATENOLOL
AMBIEN
ATIVAN
FIORCET
KLONOPIN
TENUATE
MERIDIA
XANAX
OXYCODONE
HOODIA
PHENTERMINE
TYLENOL
SOMA
ADDERALL
ACOMPLIA
VARDENAFIL
BONTRIL
ATENOLOL
LORAZEPAM
SILDENAFIL
ZYBAN
ALLEGRA
VIAGRA
CIPRO
MERIDIA
RENOVA
CODEINE
ULTRACET
XENICAL
VALTREX
TENUATE
WELLBUTRIN
RIMONABANT
CLARITIN
AMBIEN
ZOLOFT
ADIPEX
KAMAGRA
PROZAC
ALPRAZOLAM
VICODIN
TRAMADOL
METFORMIN
CELEXA
DIAZEPAM
FLOMAX
FIORCET
ULTRAM
DETOX
ZITHROMAX
HYDROCODONE
IONAMIN
CIALIS
KLONOPIN
LEVITRA
LORTAB
PAXIL
PROPECIA
ATIVAN
ZYRTEC
VALIUM
CARISOPRODOL
TESTOSTERONE
ZOLPIDEM
CELEBREX
TADALAFIL
LEXAPRO
OXYCONTIN
MERIDIA
DETOX
TRAMADOL
PAXIL
DIAZEPAM
CLARITIN
ULTRAM
ALLEGRA
CODEINE
VALIUM
PROZAC
ZOLOFT
FLOMAX
CARISOPRODOL
VIAGRA
ADDERALL
LORAZEPAM
METFORMIN
XANAX
LORTAB
TYLENOL
XENICAL
ZOLPIDEM
HYDROCODONE
CELEXA
TADALAFIL
KLONOPIN
FIORCET
IONAMIN
ACOMPLIA
ATIVAN
RIMONABANT
LEVITRA
SILDENAFIL
AMBIEN
VICODIN
RENOVA
ZITHROMAX
VARDENAFIL
PROPECIA
CELEBREX
WELLBUTRIN
TENUATE
ADIPEX
CIPRO
ULTRACET
HOODIA
OXYCODONE
SOMA
CIALIS
ALPRAZOLAM
ZYBAN
ZYRTEC
ATENOLOL
OXYCONTIN
PHENTERMINE
LEXAPRO
BONTRIL
VALTREX
TESTOSTERONE
KAMAGRA
OXYCONTIN
VIAGRA
BONTRIL
OXYCODONE
HOODIA
ZOLPIDEM
ZITHROMAX
TRAMADOL
ULTRACET
ULTRAM
FLOMAX
ATENOLOL
LEXAPRO
LORAZEPAM
VARDENAFIL
ZOLOFT
ADIPEX
CIPRO
CELEXA
PROZAC
PAXIL
VICODIN
VALTREX
TYLENOL
ADDERALL
CODEINE
CIALIS
CLARITIN
TENUATE
RENOVA
SILDENAFIL
IONAMIN
ZYRTEC
AMBIEN
SOMA
TADALAFIL
FIORCET
TESTOSTERONE
WELLBUTRIN
LEVITRA
PROPECIA
CELEBREX
CARISOPRODOL
ZYBAN
METFORMIN
ALPRAZOLAM
XANAX
MERIDIA
VALIUM
XENICAL
KAMAGRA
ACOMPLIA
ALLEGRA
DETOX
KLONOPIN
DIAZEPAM
LORTAB
HYDROCODONE
RIMONABANT
ATIVAN
PHENTERMINE
ALLEGRA
ULTRAM
VALTREX
LORTAB
TADALAFIL
HYDROCODONE
XENICAL
TYLENOL
DIAZEPAM
ZOLOFT
WELLBUTRIN
VIAGRA
PROPECIA
PHENTERMINE
RENOVA
OXYCODONE
ACOMPLIA
SILDENAFIL
TESTOSTERONE
CIPRO
IONAMIN
ULTRACET
XANAX
CELEBREX
METFORMIN
DETOX
CARISOPRODOL
RIMONABANT
FIORCET
ZITHROMAX
ATENOLOL
OXYCONTIN
ZYRTEC
KLONOPIN
CLARITIN
AMBIEN
KAMAGRA
CIALIS
FLOMAX
ZOLPIDEM
LEXAPRO
ATIVAN
PROZAC
SOMA
BONTRIL
ADIPEX
VARDENAFIL
LEVITRA
ZYBAN
TRAMADOL
MERIDIA
LORAZEPAM
CODEINE
CELEXA
VALIUM
ALPRAZOLAM
VICODIN
ADDERALL
HOODIA
TENUATE
PAXIL
ALLEGRA
ULTRAM
VALTREX
LORTAB
TADALAFIL
XENICAL
HYDROCODONE
TYLENOL
DIAZEPAM
ZOLOFT
WELLBUTRIN
VIAGRA
PHENTERMINE
RENOVA
PROPECIA
OXYCODONE
SILDENAFIL
ACOMPLIA
TESTOSTERONE
ULTRACET
CIPRO
IONAMIN
CELEBREX
XANAX
METFORMIN
FIORCET
RIMONABANT
DETOX
CARISOPRODOL
ZITHROMAX